終於有新聞了 - 期貨

By Hedwig
at 2011-01-28T01:28
at 2011-01-28T01:28
Table of Contents
嗯,這問題今天去請教過比較有瞭解背景的律師朋友,
他說的跟之前討論的一樣,慣例上會以責任歸屬的輕重
來衡量,不是一番兩瞪眼法條翻出來就可以認定,要這樣
根本不需要法官了,我們只需要一本書。
請教他最重要的一點,責任法官可能怎麼認定..
原則上,券商會吃絕大部分的虧損,
又問,那沙大這邊是不是三十萬?他說:
不太可能,推論起來,期貨市場至今已經成立十多年了,
累計成交的口數上億口,有這麼多成交的經驗,卻第一次發生
這樣的案例而上法院..
法官不可能完全讓另一方無須負擔任何責任,他會想,
市場運作了這麼久,累積上億口的經驗,為什麼這麼多
交易者都不會發生的問題,發生在你身上? 接著就會開始
斟酌-->在成交量稀疏的商品下大量的市價單,或多或少有
人為疏失,不能全部推給另一方的系統(原因就是市場已經有
上億口的實際交易,如果這是重大BUG,不可能只發生在沙大身上)
大概就是這樣,希望不要上法院,這樣就完美解決了。
一旦上法院絕對不是一番兩瞪眼的翻法條而已。民法是
超級複雜的東西..可以旁徵博引的條文太多了,到底要適用
哪一條,每一個法官都不見得會相同。
--
他說的跟之前討論的一樣,慣例上會以責任歸屬的輕重
來衡量,不是一番兩瞪眼法條翻出來就可以認定,要這樣
根本不需要法官了,我們只需要一本書。
請教他最重要的一點,責任法官可能怎麼認定..
原則上,券商會吃絕大部分的虧損,
又問,那沙大這邊是不是三十萬?他說:
不太可能,推論起來,期貨市場至今已經成立十多年了,
累計成交的口數上億口,有這麼多成交的經驗,卻第一次發生
這樣的案例而上法院..
法官不可能完全讓另一方無須負擔任何責任,他會想,
市場運作了這麼久,累積上億口的經驗,為什麼這麼多
交易者都不會發生的問題,發生在你身上? 接著就會開始
斟酌-->在成交量稀疏的商品下大量的市價單,或多或少有
人為疏失,不能全部推給另一方的系統(原因就是市場已經有
上億口的實際交易,如果這是重大BUG,不可能只發生在沙大身上)
大概就是這樣,希望不要上法院,這樣就完美解決了。
一旦上法院絕對不是一番兩瞪眼的翻法條而已。民法是
超級複雜的東西..可以旁徵博引的條文太多了,到底要適用
哪一條,每一個法官都不見得會相同。
--
Tags:
期貨
All Comments

By Olga
at 2011-01-31T17:06
at 2011-01-31T17:06

By Agatha
at 2011-02-03T11:14
at 2011-02-03T11:14

By Sierra Rose
at 2011-02-04T18:38
at 2011-02-04T18:38

By Kristin
at 2011-02-08T01:52
at 2011-02-08T01:52

By Eden
at 2011-02-08T20:50
at 2011-02-08T20:50

By Margaret
at 2011-02-11T23:12
at 2011-02-11T23:12

By Connor
at 2011-02-16T11:16
at 2011-02-16T11:16

By Elma
at 2011-02-21T03:17
at 2011-02-21T03:17

By Skylar Davis
at 2011-02-21T09:56
at 2011-02-21T09:56

By Annie
at 2011-02-23T19:37
at 2011-02-23T19:37

By Dora
at 2011-02-25T14:37
at 2011-02-25T14:37

By Tracy
at 2011-02-27T22:53
at 2011-02-27T22:53

By Rebecca
at 2011-03-04T20:18
at 2011-03-04T20:18

By Kumar
at 2011-03-09T08:50
at 2011-03-09T08:50

By John
at 2011-03-11T04:59
at 2011-03-11T04:59

By Leila
at 2011-03-11T19:39
at 2011-03-11T19:39

By Quintina
at 2011-03-16T04:05
at 2011-03-16T04:05

By Jacob
at 2011-03-19T12:57
at 2011-03-19T12:57

By Todd Johnson
at 2011-03-23T15:28
at 2011-03-23T15:28

By Rebecca
at 2011-03-25T04:48
at 2011-03-25T04:48

By Annie
at 2011-03-26T15:02
at 2011-03-26T15:02

By Elma
at 2011-03-28T05:51
at 2011-03-28T05:51

By Joseph
at 2011-03-30T07:29
at 2011-03-30T07:29

By Tracy
at 2011-03-31T18:03
at 2011-03-31T18:03

By Ida
at 2011-04-04T05:56
at 2011-04-04T05:56

By Daph Bay
at 2011-04-05T06:32
at 2011-04-05T06:32

By Jake
at 2011-04-07T10:37
at 2011-04-07T10:37

By Sarah
at 2011-04-10T17:24
at 2011-04-10T17:24

By Madame
at 2011-04-10T21:57
at 2011-04-10T21:57

By Jake
at 2011-04-14T09:20
at 2011-04-14T09:20

By Agnes
at 2011-04-18T06:32
at 2011-04-18T06:32

By Hazel
at 2011-04-19T01:56
at 2011-04-19T01:56

By Irma
at 2011-04-20T17:32
at 2011-04-20T17:32

By Madame
at 2011-04-24T09:26
at 2011-04-24T09:26

By Agatha
at 2011-04-27T17:03
at 2011-04-27T17:03

By Quintina
at 2011-04-30T16:39
at 2011-04-30T16:39

By Kama
at 2011-05-05T03:59
at 2011-05-05T03:59

By Leila
at 2011-05-09T04:45
at 2011-05-09T04:45

By Selena
at 2011-05-12T16:47
at 2011-05-12T16:47

By Michael
at 2011-05-12T22:52
at 2011-05-12T22:52

By Emily
at 2011-05-17T13:45
at 2011-05-17T13:45

By Adele
at 2011-05-22T01:52
at 2011-05-22T01:52

By Robert
at 2011-05-26T22:12
at 2011-05-26T22:12

By Quanna
at 2011-05-31T12:17
at 2011-05-31T12:17

By Robert
at 2011-06-02T14:32
at 2011-06-02T14:32

By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-06-05T04:39
at 2011-06-05T04:39

By Yedda
at 2011-06-07T10:34
at 2011-06-07T10:34

By Kristin
at 2011-06-08T03:29
at 2011-06-08T03:29

By Audriana
at 2011-06-10T07:57
at 2011-06-10T07:57

By Yedda
at 2011-06-10T11:57
at 2011-06-10T11:57

By Lauren
at 2011-06-12T14:13
at 2011-06-12T14:13

By Sarah
at 2011-06-17T05:44
at 2011-06-17T05:44

By Sandy
at 2011-06-18T17:51
at 2011-06-18T17:51
Related Posts
100年01月28日 盤中閒聊

By Steve
at 2011-01-28T01:10
at 2011-01-28T01:10
金管會函釋期貨商管理規則第二十三條第四款規定

By Oliver
at 2011-01-28T00:59
at 2011-01-28T00:59
終於有新聞了

By George
at 2011-01-27T23:22
at 2011-01-27T23:22
終於有新聞了

By Madame
at 2011-01-27T23:11
at 2011-01-27T23:11
終於有新聞了

By George
at 2011-01-27T23:05
at 2011-01-27T23:05