請教有關自然人報稅被罰問題(夫妻合併申報) - 稅務
![Suhail Hany avatar](/img/cat2.jpg)
By Suhail Hany
at 2010-03-15T17:33
at 2010-03-15T17:33
Table of Contents
上星期家裡來了一份公文, 大意是我96年度報稅時虛報了扣除額
所以現在要補繳稅跟罰金.
目前我是對罰金部分有點不滿, 所以想先請教各位, 是否有機會申訴成功.
下一步再去申訴
1. 重要日期:
民國97年5/3 我結婚, 5/5登記, 5/7進行報稅
2. 報稅方式:
自然人憑證
3. 被罰理由:
民國97年是報96年度的稅, 因此97年結婚的我, 不適用夫妻合併.
且因為妻子是國小教師, 不會有薪資所得, 所以我可以多拿到扣除額,
且不用加總妻子的薪資, 故成為虛報扣除額
(我必須先說我不曉得我當年不能跟我妻子合併申報, 這個事實是等我收到公文
才曉得有這個規定, 經過請看下列4)
4. 事情經過:
如果是使用自然人憑證, 一定會填寫一欄個人資料, 會問說是否已婚.
當時我認為我5/5已登記, 且5/3已公開宴客, 所以我寫了我已婚.
我自己還認為這樣算是誠實填寫.
問題在於, 自然人憑證也的確抓到我太太的資料, 當時薪資也為"0"(國小教師).
所以我覺得一切都很正常.
接下來進行的是三種報稅的試算, 連軟體都寫說請選擇對自己最有利的方式.
我當時選擇夫妻合併, 所以當太太薪資為0, 我就變成擁有兩倍的扣除額.
(但稅法的確規定當時我不能用合併)
我不滿的點在於, 我誠實填寫我的資料"已婚", 並填寫我太太資訊也抓得到.
理應知道我們結婚的日期, 卻不在夫妻合併部分作"禁止選取"的動作.
這對一個"不曉得這個規定的人", 不是變相地變成"引導犯罪"?
且反過來講, 如果我知道這個規定,
是不是就要故意去選取一個對自己比較不利的方式?
或者是根本寫我"未婚", 也不用考慮夫妻合併的問題
(但這明顯不誠實,反而讓人覺得日後站不住腳)
這不管怎麼想, 都應該是應該"先由軟體去做好正確規範".
因為今天詢問國稅局人員, 他說要加罰罰金.
我自己認為補繳稅金部分合理, 但是罰金部分卻是相當有爭議.
因為我是使用國稅局軟體, 一步一步做, 為什麼要承受這種莫名的罪名?
所以想請教有經驗的人, 這樣的申訴狀況是否站得住腳?
且, 如果要"有效地"申訴, 我應該採取什麼樣的管道比較好?
謝謝.
--
所以現在要補繳稅跟罰金.
目前我是對罰金部分有點不滿, 所以想先請教各位, 是否有機會申訴成功.
下一步再去申訴
1. 重要日期:
民國97年5/3 我結婚, 5/5登記, 5/7進行報稅
2. 報稅方式:
自然人憑證
3. 被罰理由:
民國97年是報96年度的稅, 因此97年結婚的我, 不適用夫妻合併.
且因為妻子是國小教師, 不會有薪資所得, 所以我可以多拿到扣除額,
且不用加總妻子的薪資, 故成為虛報扣除額
(我必須先說我不曉得我當年不能跟我妻子合併申報, 這個事實是等我收到公文
才曉得有這個規定, 經過請看下列4)
4. 事情經過:
如果是使用自然人憑證, 一定會填寫一欄個人資料, 會問說是否已婚.
當時我認為我5/5已登記, 且5/3已公開宴客, 所以我寫了我已婚.
我自己還認為這樣算是誠實填寫.
問題在於, 自然人憑證也的確抓到我太太的資料, 當時薪資也為"0"(國小教師).
所以我覺得一切都很正常.
接下來進行的是三種報稅的試算, 連軟體都寫說請選擇對自己最有利的方式.
我當時選擇夫妻合併, 所以當太太薪資為0, 我就變成擁有兩倍的扣除額.
(但稅法的確規定當時我不能用合併)
我不滿的點在於, 我誠實填寫我的資料"已婚", 並填寫我太太資訊也抓得到.
理應知道我們結婚的日期, 卻不在夫妻合併部分作"禁止選取"的動作.
這對一個"不曉得這個規定的人", 不是變相地變成"引導犯罪"?
且反過來講, 如果我知道這個規定,
是不是就要故意去選取一個對自己比較不利的方式?
或者是根本寫我"未婚", 也不用考慮夫妻合併的問題
(但這明顯不誠實,反而讓人覺得日後站不住腳)
這不管怎麼想, 都應該是應該"先由軟體去做好正確規範".
因為今天詢問國稅局人員, 他說要加罰罰金.
我自己認為補繳稅金部分合理, 但是罰金部分卻是相當有爭議.
因為我是使用國稅局軟體, 一步一步做, 為什麼要承受這種莫名的罪名?
所以想請教有經驗的人, 這樣的申訴狀況是否站得住腳?
且, 如果要"有效地"申訴, 我應該採取什麼樣的管道比較好?
謝謝.
--
Tags:
稅務
All Comments
![Irma avatar](/img/woman.jpg)
By Irma
at 2010-03-17T12:10
at 2010-03-17T12:10
![Elvira avatar](/img/woman-biz.jpg)
By Elvira
at 2010-03-21T04:24
at 2010-03-21T04:24
![Genevieve avatar](/img/woman-glasses.jpg)
By Genevieve
at 2010-03-22T12:44
at 2010-03-22T12:44
![Rachel avatar](/img/woman-ring.jpg)
By Rachel
at 2010-03-22T17:24
at 2010-03-22T17:24
![Lydia avatar](/img/cat1.jpg)
By Lydia
at 2010-03-25T09:34
at 2010-03-25T09:34
![Dorothy avatar](/img/cat2.jpg)
By Dorothy
at 2010-03-28T06:09
at 2010-03-28T06:09
![Yuri avatar](/img/cat3.jpg)
By Yuri
at 2010-03-29T09:17
at 2010-03-29T09:17
![Kumar avatar](/img/cat4.jpg)
By Kumar
at 2010-03-31T23:14
at 2010-03-31T23:14
![Jacky avatar](/img/cat3.jpg)
By Jacky
at 2010-04-01T23:55
at 2010-04-01T23:55
![Odelette avatar](/img/cat4.jpg)
By Odelette
at 2010-04-02T03:20
at 2010-04-02T03:20
![Rebecca avatar](/img/cat5.jpg)
By Rebecca
at 2010-04-05T14:45
at 2010-04-05T14:45
![Odelette avatar](/img/cat5.jpg)
By Odelette
at 2010-04-09T01:44
at 2010-04-09T01:44
![Sarah avatar](/img/girl.jpg)
By Sarah
at 2010-04-11T17:34
at 2010-04-11T17:34
![Freda avatar](/img/girl1.jpg)
By Freda
at 2010-04-13T20:40
at 2010-04-13T20:40
![Kumar avatar](/img/girl2.jpg)
By Kumar
at 2010-04-16T18:27
at 2010-04-16T18:27
![Rosalind avatar](/img/girl3.jpg)
By Rosalind
at 2010-04-21T05:33
at 2010-04-21T05:33
![Emily avatar](/img/girl4.jpg)
By Emily
at 2010-04-23T23:45
at 2010-04-23T23:45
![Charlotte avatar](/img/girl5.jpg)
By Charlotte
at 2010-04-25T22:55
at 2010-04-25T22:55
![Freda avatar](/img/woman.jpg)
By Freda
at 2010-04-28T16:21
at 2010-04-28T16:21
![Olga avatar](/img/dog1.jpg)
By Olga
at 2010-04-30T08:54
at 2010-04-30T08:54
![Lydia avatar](/img/woman-biz.jpg)
By Lydia
at 2010-05-01T05:32
at 2010-05-01T05:32
![Vanessa avatar](/img/woman-glasses.jpg)
By Vanessa
at 2010-05-05T03:52
at 2010-05-05T03:52
![Lydia avatar](/img/woman-ring.jpg)
By Lydia
at 2010-05-06T10:29
at 2010-05-06T10:29
![Zanna avatar](/img/cat1.jpg)
By Zanna
at 2010-05-07T14:03
at 2010-05-07T14:03
![Ivy avatar](/img/cat2.jpg)
By Ivy
at 2010-05-09T22:27
at 2010-05-09T22:27
![Caroline avatar](/img/cat3.jpg)
By Caroline
at 2010-05-12T04:15
at 2010-05-12T04:15
![Odelette avatar](/img/dog2.jpg)
By Odelette
at 2010-05-12T12:54
at 2010-05-12T12:54
![Isla avatar](/img/cat4.jpg)
By Isla
at 2010-05-14T10:06
at 2010-05-14T10:06
![Kama avatar](/img/cat5.jpg)
By Kama
at 2010-05-18T10:58
at 2010-05-18T10:58
![Victoria avatar](/img/girl.jpg)
By Victoria
at 2010-05-23T10:45
at 2010-05-23T10:45
![Rachel avatar](/img/girl1.jpg)
By Rachel
at 2010-05-28T07:37
at 2010-05-28T07:37
![Ingrid avatar](/img/girl2.jpg)
By Ingrid
at 2010-05-30T10:00
at 2010-05-30T10:00
![Joe avatar](/img/elephant.jpg)
By Joe
at 2010-06-03T15:46
at 2010-06-03T15:46
![Dora avatar](/img/girl3.jpg)
By Dora
at 2010-06-06T05:02
at 2010-06-06T05:02
![Necoo avatar](/img/girl4.jpg)
By Necoo
at 2010-06-08T03:39
at 2010-06-08T03:39
![Annie avatar](/img/girl5.jpg)
By Annie
at 2010-06-12T17:36
at 2010-06-12T17:36
![Carol avatar](/img/woman.jpg)
By Carol
at 2010-06-17T11:34
at 2010-06-17T11:34
![John avatar](/img/beaver.jpg)
By John
at 2010-06-19T01:54
at 2010-06-19T01:54
![Sandy avatar](/img/woman-biz.jpg)
By Sandy
at 2010-06-21T14:41
at 2010-06-21T14:41
![Lydia avatar](/img/woman-glasses.jpg)
By Lydia
at 2010-06-24T00:35
at 2010-06-24T00:35
![Hedy avatar](/img/woman-ring.jpg)
By Hedy
at 2010-06-24T15:33
at 2010-06-24T15:33
![Wallis avatar](/img/bee.jpg)
By Wallis
at 2010-06-27T01:54
at 2010-06-27T01:54
![Oscar avatar](/img/beret.jpg)
By Oscar
at 2010-06-30T07:28
at 2010-06-30T07:28
![Gilbert avatar](/img/boy1.jpg)
By Gilbert
at 2010-06-30T10:57
at 2010-06-30T10:57
![Olivia avatar](/img/cat1.jpg)
By Olivia
at 2010-07-01T00:41
at 2010-07-01T00:41
Related Posts
捐贈抵稅的問題
![Kyle avatar](/img/cat3.jpg)
By Kyle
at 2010-03-15T00:05
at 2010-03-15T00:05
房租抵稅的問題
![Steve avatar](/img/boy1.jpg)
By Steve
at 2010-03-15T00:00
at 2010-03-15T00:00
遠低於課稅門檻的收入要報稅嗎?
![Quanna avatar](/img/woman-ring.jpg)
By Quanna
at 2010-03-14T19:39
at 2010-03-14T19:39
怎麼檢舉月營業額超過20萬的小吃攤?
![Isabella avatar](/img/cat5.jpg)
By Isabella
at 2010-03-14T12:33
at 2010-03-14T12:33
父母離婚後的撫養問題
![Zanna avatar](/img/cat2.jpg)
By Zanna
at 2010-03-14T12:09
at 2010-03-14T12:09